Guide To Choosing Keel Coolers; "Studs" vs "Threads" Zincs or no Zincs

Stud fitting (PN E50722) VS Thread fitting (PNE50361)
Both of these keel coolers require a 1 1/2" hole for mounting, & the "exterior" parts are identical. The "Threads" model has just that, a threaded portion inside the boat & a big nut that is screwed down tight on to the stainless steel backing plate that is provided. This is very similar to most other thru-hull fittings including instrument transducers & water intakes & discharges, and it requires that a large wrench be swung with a fair amount of force in a large radius. Unless the exterior portion is held steady by either jamming in pieces of wood or by a strong helper, the whole fitting with tend to rotate as the nut is tightened.

The "Studs" model has two studs that protrude from the top of the interior portion of the fitting, & over each of these is slipped a stainless steel  bar followed by a washer & nut. There is a selection of different size collars provided (to accommodate different hull thickness), & the appropriate one is chosen & then installed between the bars & the stainless steel backing plate that is provided. The two nuts can now be gently tightened with a 1/2" socket. This advantages of this fitting are that it can be installed in a tight area where there is not the room to swing a wrench, & there is no need to restrain the fitting as it will not rotate when tightened.

Zincs or No Zincs? PN E500722Z) & PNE50361Z
Both types of keel cooler, "Threads" & "Studs", are available with two, circular, flush mounted sacrificial zincs installed in the bottom. These models are identical in size & shape to the non-zinc types & are distinguished by a "Z" following the Part Number. Most modern boats will have a bonding system that essentially connects bronze thru-hulls electrically to each other and to a sacrificial zinc anode that is mounted either on the prop the shaft or the hull, & is also connected to the battery negative. The higher voltage of the zinc protects the other thru-hull fittings, and slowly sacrifices some of its metal. The sintered bronze & cupro-nickel that is used in the construction of the keel cooler is compatible with other marine-grade bronze & brass fittings, &, as the keel cooler must be connected to the battery negative (as a safety precaution), the fitting will normally be protected by the boats shaft or hull zinc. If the boat has no bonding system or has non-metalic fittings& all thru-hulls & the prop shaft are electrically isolated (there will still be shaft or prop zinc), then the installation of a keel cooler with zincs is recommended because the fitting will be connected electrically to the battery negative, & any stray or corrosion currents can use this path.

There is no difference in performance between a keel cooler with zincs or without zincs, & if one is installed with zincs in an application that does not require them, the zincs will still erode & require changing periodically. In all cases, we strongly recommend the use of a temporary "guppy" zinc while the boat is at the dock or on a mooring, & the installation of a "Zinc Saver" or similar device.

 

 

First Mate's Cabin
Van Buren, OH 45889
PH: (419) 299-3862
Fax: (419) 299-3032
Email: firstmatescabin@aol.com